@Irishk,
Warning, spoilers.
Just finished it, I liked it! I've been reading a fair amount of modern romance novel-type stuff (not outright Fabio cover romance novels, but the chick lit versions that usually have covers with white backgrounds featuring beautifully photographed shoes or women with obscured faces and fabulous clothes) for this book club and it annoyed me that this book (
Guernsey...) ended up fitting right smack dab into that formula. Smart, gorgeous, post-30 single lady with a career just wants to find a nice man and by the end of the book she has a) rejected the cad for b) the nice guy and c) wound up with a ready-made family made up of herself, nice guy and d) the adorable urchin who she has bonded with before realizing that she's mother material, after all.
If the formula is removed, though, the actual writing is pretty good, especially Juliet's "voice" (via letters) and many of the details were interesting.