Not quite the same thing, re the emotions involved, but interesting - from The Art Newspaper:
The day my son smashed my Grayson Perry pot
Funerary Urn was broken into over 25 pieces by a bouncing ball
By Louisa Buck | Posted 30 November 2006
Funerary Urn in pieces
The sound of a Grayson Perry pot hitting quarry tiles is one that will remain with me forever. I have been friends with the artist for over 20 years and own a number of his works, but Funerary Urn was a particular favourite. I first spotted it across a seething private view at the now defunct Birch and Conran gallery in Soho in 1988, and knew that I had to have it. I loved its occult elegance and mischievous inscriptions, each of which seemed deliberately designed to deter any purchaser. One side declared that "in this urn are contained the ashes of potter Grayson Perry and his lifelong companion Claire", while the other delivered the disquieting news that "Grayson Perry made this urn to earn the money to buy the motorcycle on which he was killed". Defiantly ignoring any potential bad Karma,
I parted with the then (for me) considerable sum of £400, and the pot was mine.
Over the years, Funerary Urn survived three house moves, a multitude of drunken parties and one car crash. But it proved to be no match for two bored teenagers and a gym ball on a Saturday afternoon last year. I asked my son and his friend to stop bouncing the ball. They rolled their eyes. I even pointed to Funerary Urn, perched precariously on a nearby mantelpiece. As I left the room the bouncing started again. And then that unforgettable crash. At least the guilty pair had the decency to look appalled. Funerary Urn in smithereens was a terrible sight. Weeping, I collected the myriad pieces and carefully wrapped each shard in kitchen roll. I even preserved the pulverised dust. It felt as if I was laying out a corpse.
Still sniffing, I called Grayson, who sounded shocked. He couldn't fix it, but he knew a man who possibly could. He gave me the number of his conservator. The word struck doom in my heart. I had no insurance.
Reconstructed in the hands of conservator Bouke de Vries
I left a shaky message on an answering machine. Soon I was listening to the soothing tones of Bouke de Vries, for whom calming the agitated owners of smashed ceramics is obviously part of the job. He assured me that nothing was impossible, that things always seemed worse than they were, and asked me if I had picked up and wrapped all the pieces. I took Funerary Urn, now shrouded in its own coffin, to Bouke's studio in West London and hoped for the best.
I soon discovered that I was not alone.
Heavyweight contemporary art collector David Teiger, who is based in New York, told me how his three-year-old daughter had coloured in the Andy Warhol that he bought from the artist's first exhibition (Andy's response was apparently to declare, "Now you own a Teiger!"). Another major New York collector's eyes filled with tears as he recalled how a wall-mounted Rachel Whiteread bookcase sculpture crashed to the ground in a pile of pulverised plaster (the artist made him another one) and even the widely revered collector and patron Agnes Gund once discovered that her maid had thrown away the wrapping from a Christo piece and confessed that her cats had used part of a Mary Frank sculpture as a litter tray. All of which inspired me and my co-author Judith Greer (whose own son and friends had recently smashed the glass on a Hatakeyama photo piece) to call a section of our book, "Beware Animals and Children".
So what of Funerary Urn? For a while its future seemed in abeyance as it turned out to be rather more troublesome than Bouke had originally anticipated. Perhaps the spirit of Claire was making mischief after all (certainly, in the intervening time between the pot's purchase and its fall from grace, Perry's eponymous transvestite alter-ego had mutated from demure Camilla Parker Bowles look-alike into a demonic Little Bow Peep, who looked capable of a curse or two).
Apparently it wasn't the shattered shards that were causing the problem, but the surface. Having put the pot back together, Bouke had first of all filled the gaps with a special white filler which he then retouched to match the nebulously-coloured greenish-blue, grey-black glaze. But every mark showed up. As he explained, he could have made the joins invisible with an airbrush but this would have involved repainting the entire surface of the pot. So he took the pot back into pieces and mixed pigment into the filler which, after considerable effort, eventually matched the original colour. "I decided that the best approach with this object was to do as little as possible," he said, "because it is a pot made by an artist."
Doing as little as possible still meant doing a great deal. Yet at the same time as Bouke was brilliantly repairing Funerary Urn, he was also doing something else very important. By consciously deciding against a spurious perfection which would have involved him literally painting-out the memory of the mishap, he was allowing Funerary Urn to retain both its texture and its identity. If you look closely, you can still see traces of cracks and chips but you can also see Grayson's brushstrokes?-they are all part of the character of the piece, there for all to see.
Another passage in Owning Art sternly declares "Don't Buy Art to Make Money" and frowns on those who put financial considerations before those of the art itself. Yet while I never had?-nor have?-any intention of selling Funerary Urn, I was nonetheless curious to know whether its tumble from the mantelpiece had been accompanied by an equally devastating plummet in value. But the news from Katharine Burton, specialist in contemporary art at Christie's, was surprisingly good. "Obviously everything has to be evaluated on a case-by-case basis, but given the particular circumstances and given the provenance and the fact that the pot has been restored to museum standards by the artist's chosen conservator, there shouldn't be a huge depreciation in value," she told me. "We do have to allow a little bit for the condition issue, but assuming that the artist feels the condition of the piece doesn't detract from the quality of the work as he originally intended it, then there's no real reason why it should have a major impact on its sale."
Thankfully Grayson declares himself to be content with the current incarnation of Funerary Urn. "I think it's fine, in a way it adds another layer of history to it." He told me: " It's like the Ashes, the cricketing trophy which is also that shape.
The destruction and the creation are one, and I like that a lot." So now, Funerary Urn is back on my mantelpiece, but this time it is secured by a robust Perspex bracket screwed into the wall. All exercise balls, animals and children have been banned from its vicinity. Even though, all things considered, things turned out unexpectedly well, I never, ever, want to hear the sound of that terrible crash again.
Link to Source