Setanta wrote:It is not established that the defects of the Americans stipulated are imaginary.
England lost people in the twin towers, too. And they have supported us in Afghanistan without question. They have honored our losses, and shown us a respect which attitudes such as yours suggest to me that we might not deserve.
No assertion from me that Americans or our culture are without defects. Instead, I noted that it was unnecessary and unseemly for the author of the Guardian piece to expend so much energy in a gratuitous criticism of others in what purported to be praise of the English reaction to 7/7. The implied comparison was flawed and it lowered the overall level of the article. Do you dispute that?
No complaint either with respect to the English people or the policy of their government. My comments were directed to the author and publishers of the article in question. I believe they are fully merited.
setanta wrote:You further ignore that they have a hell of a lot more experience of terrorism and its consequences than we have. The Provos invented that delightful little terrorist technique of a small explosion preceeding by a few seconds the main explosion, which then catches so many victims running away from the first explosion. They practiced and perfected the technique in England.
Have your ever donated to Noraid, Paddy?
Terrorism of various types is hardly new, either in Britain or the United States. We could as well start the clock with the Gunpowder Plot or the Seven Year's War. "Experience with Terrorism" is, in my view a somewhat over-hyped concept without as much meaning as it is usually given. Terror is simply a favored weapon of the weak against the strong in a conflict. It is as old as the history of human conflict. I believe our government makes too much of it in our "war on terrorism", just as I do those who suggest that others are meaningfully wiser and more experienced with it.
There was some years ago a well-developed support group for Noraid in Northern California. I knew some of its figures peripherally and very likely was proximate to some of their events, but no, I didn't contribute directly. My name is not Paddy.