FreeDuck wrote:In the case of pharmacists, I definitely agree. Their job is to fill prescriptions and not to decide whether a person should or should not be prescribed it. If they can't just fill the bottle, they should find another job, personal reasons or not.
As a believer in freedom of contract, I disagree. If I own a liquor shop selling Bordeaux and Montepulciano, and you want Pinot Noir, I can choose not to sell it to you, and you can choose to buy at another liquor shop. You have a right to buy Pinot Noir from whoever wants to sell it to you, but you have no right to me wanting to sell it, nor to sell it against my will.
When you order a morning-after pill in a pharmacy, the case is similar. If I own a pharmacy that has condoms and contraception pills, but no morning-after pills, you have a right to buy morning after pills from whoever wants to sell them to you. But as in the case of the Pinot Noir, you have no right to me wanting to sell it, and you cannot forcibly make me sell it against my will.
The case is different if I am not the owner, but an employee of the business you're dealing with. If my duties involve selling morning-after pills or prescribing poison, my employer can fire me for failing to perform on my work contract. But he can do that whether I decline to perform for religious reasons, or because I'm just in a nasty mood today.