3
   

Too many characters for a short story?

 
 
Reply Sun 27 Jun, 2021 04:09 pm
Hello there,

I am working on a short fiction piece (maybe 3,000 words or less) about an incompetent female security guard who experiences a robbery at the bank she is supposed to be protecting and then witnesses one of the robbers get nearly beaten to death by his other accomplices. (Although she is almost discovered by the other robbers they for the most part never catch her in her hiding place).

She develops a crush on the beaten robber as she feels she relates to him a little. Although she does call the police she knows she will eventually get fired by the bank/her security agency and then maybe out of a moment of despair/rebellion decides to rescue the nearly dead robber by taking him to her home and caring for him. They eventually bond and then leave town to avoid apprehension by the law.

The problem I have with this is that one of my former editors told me that too many characters/scenes and/or action in a short story short-changes the characterization as it doesn't really give the characters a chance to develop. However, I intend to make the lead male character's fellow robbers extremely minor without really describing them (she can't really see them from her hiding spot and is too scared to think about them like that anyway) and I get rid of them all in the first scene. Much of the story focuses on her and the robber she falls in love with and it takes place in her small apartment with both of them talking and interacting while he is bed-ridden from his injuries.

Bear in mind, I also know some parts of this seem silly and disjointed but I also intend for much of it to be darkly comedic, for that element of comic relief. The story focuses on the guard's low self-esteem resulting from past childhood abuse which affects her work performance and interactions with her workmates, overall social life etc. and this criminal, (also formerly a battered child), is ironically the only person in her life who makes her feel good about herself again.
 
edgarblythe
 
  2  
Reply Sun 27 Jun, 2021 04:15 pm
If it reads well and the extra characters cannot confuse readers I say do it your way.
0 Replies
 
jespah
 
  3  
Reply Sun 27 Jun, 2021 06:26 pm
@RosyDoll,
Main thing is to be sure the voices of the characters ring true and feel distinguishable. With 3k words, you don't have a lot of time to play with nuance, so the distinguishing marks need to be easy and quick to understand.

Such as -
  1. Jack uses a crutch
  2. Maria talks with a lisp
  3. Helene is prejudiced
  4. Louis swears a lot
  5. Kerry is taller than everyone else and they all have to look up to her
  6. Ryan is older than everyone else and moves more slowly
With a list of characters like this, everyone is easy to pick out, and three of the characters even have different ways of speaking, which makes them even easier to tell apart. Also, the names are different from each other. If characters are named Patsy, Patrick, Patrice, and Patti-Ann, readers are going to have a hard time telling them apart.

Best of luck to you with your story. Writing's a blast! Smile
0 Replies
 
RosyDoll
 
  1  
Reply Mon 28 Jun, 2021 02:06 pm
This is great, thanks so much guys and be blessed. ❤
0 Replies
 
farmerman
 
  1  
Reply Mon 28 Jun, 2021 02:41 pm
Elmore Leonard (author of Get Shorty) always said about short stories.


Make something happen but not too much. (he never gave more advice than that. tephen King would always write "how to" books about his novels ans short stories. He always said that his short stories were always there toanswer ONE question with as few xharactersas possible.

I love reading "How to" stuff about writing but I have NO WRITING TALENT OR SKILLS that Im aware of
0 Replies
 
 

 
  1. Forums
  2. » Too many characters for a short story?
Copyright © 2024 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.03 seconds on 11/07/2024 at 03:37:47