@Roberta,
I didn't know
Potsy was considered a girl's game. Both girls and boys played in on our block. We called it
Potsy but it looked a lot like what's called
Hopscotch. Is there a difference between the two?
Straight Tag and numerous versions (Freeze, Cigarette, Flashlight, Team etc) were very popular.
Along with baseball and football on the field in my best friend's backyard (Actually it wasn't a field as much as a ruined lawn, but it served our purposes very well) we conducted track meets (handing out colored ribbons to the first three finishers of each event), stick-ball with a broom stick and a red spaldeen in the street, and for a short period of time one Summer, boxing matches, but that's a tale for another time.
Someone's father once tried to get us to play
Johnny on the Pony a game from his childhood days in NYC, but while we were more than up for rough and tumble games, right away someone hurt their back and everyone expressed the fear of becoming paralyzed by a stupid game that wasn't even fun.
A couple of kids would always try and get us to play
Ring a Levio probably because they had already spent 5 or 6 years living in the City where, apparently it was common, but we never figured out the rules and it was cast on the dustbin of street and yard games.
Giant Steps and
Mother May I were good when the gang was limited to four or five kids.
Cowboys & Indians was huge. Early on, at the start of any game play everyone would shout
"I'm Roy Rogers!" and then we would argue about who claimed the title first. As we aged and TV Westerns filled the airwaves there was always a wide selection of characters to assume. My brother, much to my undying shame, always chose Tom "Sugarfoot" Brewster. My best friend Finn D (we obviously shared the same first name) always went with Flint McCullough the scout from
Wagon Train but once I got past my obsession with Roy Rogers, I didn't have a single go-to cowboy. Despite my relatively small stature, I often chose to play Cheyenne Brody and would rotate through Christopher Colt from
Colt .45, Brent Maverick, Wild Bill Hickok (Eventually retired him from the rotation because I felt he needed a Jingles and for some reason none of the other kids would play the Andy Devine role), Jim Bowie, all three of the Disney Western characters: Zorro, Texas John Slaughter and El Fego Baca, Josh Randall, Steve McQueen's character in
Wanted Dead or Alive, and frequently Cochise from
Broken Arrow.
The keys to a successful game were twofold:
Equipment: In those days most of the Western characters had signature hats and weapons, and just about all of them were replicated by toy companies and available to kids with some money. If you were one of three being raised by a single mother like Finn D, funds were short, but he always managed to find the cheapest and coolest equipment. A beat up black cowboy hat from the Farmer's Market was a near perfect replica of the hat his favorite cowboy wore and his most prized possession was a toy pistol his grandmother bought him and which looked very authentic. The unfortunate economics of his family was probably one of the reasons he never played any cowboy but the one he could replicate so well, Flint McCullough.
Our family was hardly wealthy, but we were upwardly mobile and at the top of the economic ladder in our neighborhood, so if I asked for something reasonable for my birthday or Christmas, I often got it. Plus I had a generous, indulgent paternal grandmother who only had us three grandkids (my maternal grandmother had over 20, and dead husband who had been a lush and left her penniless so if we got a nickel from her we were delighted - it bought a candy bar!) As a result I was much better equipped than most of the other kids and could switch roles with ease.
I had two hats, one light brown and the other black and a collection of weapon sets including Jim Bowie's huge knife, Yancy Derringer's auto-flick derringer (the contraption strapped to your forearm and when the spring was released, flipped the small gun towards your palm. He didn't work well enough to regularly play Yancy but it was very cool for the first couple of days), an entire Zorro getup including hat, mask, cape and sword (the hat was unfortunately cheesy plastic and so Zorro often changed his headgear to a standard black cowboy hat) and an Indian getup including warpaint for Cochise. My most treasured weapon though was Steve McQueen's "Mare's Leg," a shortened Winchester rifle with a properly sized holster so you could wear it at your hip and draw it like a gunslinger.
Storytelling: We made up the plots of our episodes as we went along, sometimes drawing on what we had recently seen on a TV show and sometimes creating original material on the fly. Everyone involved had the opportunity to suggest the scene or series of actions, but it usually fell to three of us: me, Finn D and his older sister Laura who was a tom-boy and the only kid in our gang who could beat-up Finn D. Every kid created a signature sound for his weapon and if you could mimic a convincing richochet sound it garnered status. Johhny Nasty, for some reason, insisted on using the sound "Da da... da da da" I guess it was easy for rapid fire sound effects but we all agreed it made it seem like his gun was retarded (a permitted adjective at the time). The stories we spun never had set endings, we just fought outlaws and Indians, saved homesteaders from floods and bears, and got out of one jam after another until we were tired, hungry or it was time to go home.