Reply
Tue 10 Jan, 2017 03:51 am
Being the only child in the family, Peter was spoilt by his parents from a young age.
Is "was spoilt" correct? Shouldn't it be "has been spoilt"?
Thanks.
If he is no longer being spoilt, e.g. because he is an adult and is no longer living with his parents, then use 'was spoilt', or if the spoiling has continued up to the present time, use 'has been spoilt'. Note that certain British English past participles ending in -t such as burnt spoilt learnt learnt etc are considered errors in US English, which prefers -ed endings.
To avoid alienating potential helpers, you should probably try to avoid posting begging messages ("please help") if possible, and definitely wait more than four hours after posting your question.
@centrox,
centrox wrote:learnt learnt
Sorry for the repetition. I offer spelt as a substitute.
@centrox,
centrox wrote:
centrox wrote:learnt learnt
Sorry for the repetition.
I offer spelt as a substitute.
Thanks, centrox.
Can you please explain the part in bold?
@tanguatlay,
tanguatlay wrote:
centrox wrote:
Sorry for the repetition. I offer spelt as a substitute.
Thanks, centrox.
Can you please explain the part in bold?
I gave a (non-exhaustive) list of past participles ending in -t: burnt spoilt learnt learnt. I included 'learnt' twice. I apologised for that error and attempted to make up for it by offering a different example, 'spelt', as a substitute for the repeated word.
Thanks, centrox.
I didn't notice that.
@tanguatlay,
Tang I think either is okay but as usu context counts for a subtle diff, eg (2) suggests (to maybe me only) that Pete is still around
Kep at it Tang, some of us admire your persistence at an impossible goal