@Roberta,
Quote:If someone asked me whether I'm superstitious, I would say no.
I would have to say I am and I can't take refuge in blaming my sub-conscious.
Not in the sense that I actually believe that harm, necessarily, follows a black cat crossing one's path, a broken mirror, walking under a ladder or any of the hundreds of other supposedly sinister events we are faced with everyday, but more as an expression of OCD tendencies.
I have a certain routine that I go through in the morning that involves precise numbers of strokes from my deoderant, rinses while brushing my teeth and similar inviolate rules of the toilet. What will happen if I violate the rules? Nothing of course other than my having a sense that I've put myself in some sort of metaphysical peril. The sense lasts about as long as it takes me to leave the bathroom and begin dressing. Yet, I am religious about following the routine and the anxiety caused by breaking it, while not lasting or remotely debilitating, is momentarily unpleasant enough to enforce my efforts to follow the routine going forward.
I tend to think this is very mild OCD but I can imagine it exploding well enough to have great sympathy for those who are afflicted with a severe case of the disorder.
I'm sure all superstition can't be explained by obsessive compulsions, but a lot can.
I also think there is an underlining sense of
"Why take a chance?" Life is tough enough to get through without inviting disaster by deliberately violating one of the laws of metaphysics. A great many people follow the required response to an unfortunate event (like spilling salt) just because at some level they don't feel comfortable blatantly defying the Goddess of Luck. Along with
"Why take a chance?" comes
"You never know."
The vast majority of us don't really believe bad things will necessarily happen if we don't ward them off with a
spell. Should they fail to comply with the ritual, I suspect that most people who do throw the salt over their shoulder or knock wood, would not trace back a misfortune that befell them, later in the day, to their earlier violation. It's not a belief in magic per se, but perhaps a cultural residue from a time when magic was
real to people...and a way to hedge one's bet.
I also knock wood frequently and firmly. The notion of tempting fate has been around for a long time and ancient peoples around the globe shared a sense that it wasn't smart to draw the attention of the gods, especially through prideful boasts. I suppose it's possible that in so doing they were actually drawing the attention of criminals and that the bad result from this happened enough times that people came to think of it as an expression of the gods' displeasure with hubris, but I think not. Ancient people didn't need metaphysical forces like luck and gods to explain the results of clearly foolish behavior. I don't think there is any superstition that involves a metaphysical connection between ensuing misfortune and sticking one's hand in fire or jumping off a cliff. Similarly, shoot your mouth off about how much treasure you have in front of rogues and you're going to get robbed; not because you're unlucky or you pissed of the gods, but because you're a fool.
There is so much that has been and continues to be outside the control of individual humans and bad things come in big and small packages. It's comforting in a silly, very human way, to think that knocking wood or crossing yourself can somehow provide you with protection against things for which there really is no protection.
Why take a chance? You never know...
PS: There is nothing superstitious about the connection between your favorite sports team's success and the position in which you are sitting while you watch the game. I myself have proven this to be a scientific fact over and over again.