Looking to change away from AARP

Probably not. That was looted from Medicare Advantage. It sounds like you are talking about a Medigap policy.

http://www.medicare.gov/supplement-other-insurance/medigap/whats-medigap.html



I imagine so. There are generally a range of plans offered by a range of companies. Note though that more comprehensive coverage will usually cost more than less comprehensive coverage.

However, as I've never shopped for a Medigap policy, I've no idea how to go about shopping and comparing policies. Hopefully someone else here has had that experience and can point you in the right direction.

In my suggestion, you can move to Medicare plans A because its basic plan and easily affordable with any income.
If you move to other plan then choose retired person medicare plans. Retired health insurance plan is deduct their cost or prices after year.

There's 10 plans available, what you're paying depends on the plan you chose, the carrier you went with and your location. What letter plan do you currently have? Plan F is the most expensive because it gives you the most coverage. Plan F and N are the next best plans. AARP can charge what they want for each plan, but the benefits are the same across all carriers. Your best bet is to figure out which plan you want and then compare that plan with all the carriers in your area.