1
   

how can we prove there is a God

 
 
Reply Fri 16 Apr, 2010 06:14 am
hey:
Note: "Proving" God exists is really not our purpose. We are only interested in providing clear statements based on facts and logic and then allow the individual decide for themselves who they would like to believe. There have always been people who believed in the existence of God and there have always been those who have denied in His existence. We must realize there are those who will never believe no matter how much proof or evidence we produce. The reason is some people don't want to believe in a Creator or Sustainer. They would not like to consider one day they will have to answer for their actions and for their refusal to acknowledge their Benefactor to whom they owe their very existence. We come to know it is not so much a matter of us trying to convey our beliefs as it is for them to set aside preconceived prejudices against proper belief. Meaning: this is really a matter of guidance from Above. If they refuse even with evident proofs in front of them, this is not between us and them; it is between them and their Creator. Again, it is not our job to "prove" anything to anyone. We only need to present the facts in truth and allow the listener to make up their own mind.

We just begin with simple logic. When something is right in front of our eyes it is difficult to deny it, right? Asking rhetorical questions can be very helpful in presenting our case. Begin by asking the question; "Can you prove you exist?" Yes, of course you can. You merely use your senses to determine what you can see, hear, feel, smell, taste and you have emotions as well. All of this is a part of your existence. But this is not how we perceive God in Islam. We can look to the things He has created and the way He cares for things and sustains us, to know there is no doubt of His existence.

One approach is to suggest simple yet convincing experiments anyone could comprehend. For instance, say to someone, "Consider this the next time you are looking up at the moon or the stars on a clear night; could you drop a drinking glass on the sidewalk and expect it would hit the ground and on impact it would not shatter, but it would divide up into little small drinking glasses, with iced tea in them? Of course not."

Another example is have them consider what might happen if a tornado came through a junkyard and tore through the old cars; would it leave behind a nice new Mercedes with the engine running and no parts left around? Naturally not.

Or ask someone to consider what it would be like if someone told us about a fast food restaurant operating itself without any people there? The food just cooks itself, files from the kitchen to the table and then when we are done, the dishes jump back the kitchen to wash themselves. This is too crazy for anyone to even think about.

After reflecting on all of the above, how could we look to the universe above us through a telescope or observe the cells in a microscope and then think all of this came about as a result of a "big bang" or some "accident"?

(see also "Quran")
for more information:
Knowing Allah
thanks.
  • Topic Stats
  • Top Replies
  • Link to this Topic
Type: Discussion • Score: 1 • Views: 2,004 • Replies: 11
No top replies

 
Fatal Freedoms
 
  1  
Reply Fri 16 Apr, 2010 10:07 am
@abd alrahem,
abd alrahem;71267 wrote:
hey:
Note: "Proving" God exists is really not our purpose. We are only interested in providing clear statements based on facts and logic and then allow the individual decide for themselves who they would like to believe. There have always been people who believed in the existence of God and there have always been those who have denied in His existence. We must realize there are those who will never believe no matter how much proof or evidence we produce. The reason is some people don't want to believe in a Creator or Sustainer. They would not like to consider one day they will have to answer for their actions and for their refusal to acknowledge their Benefactor to whom they owe their very existence.


This is a common misconception.


Just as their are those who believe in God and do bad things and yet are not worried about them. There are those who don't believe in god and yet do good things.

Whether someone is or isn't afraid of the consequences is irrelevant to whether they believe in god or not. It just isn't a factor. Some people are just naturally skeptical and some people are just naturally faithful.


Quote:

We come to know it is not so much a matter of us trying to convey our beliefs as it is for them to set aside preconceived prejudices against proper belief. Meaning: this is really a matter of guidance from Above. If they refuse even with evident proofs in front of them, this is not between us and them; it is between them and their Creator. Again, it is not our job to "prove" anything to anyone. We only need to present the facts in truth and allow the listener to make up their own mind.


I'm sure you've made up your mind just as much as they have made up theirs.

Quote:
We just begin with simple logic. When something is right in front of our eyes it is difficult to deny it, right? Asking rhetorical questions can be very helpful in presenting our case. Begin by asking the question; "Can you prove you exist?" Yes, of course you can. You merely use your senses to determine what you can see, hear, feel, smell, taste and you have emotions as well. All of this is a part of your existence. But this is not how we perceive God in Islam. We can look to the things He has created and the way He cares for things and sustains us, to know there is no doubt of His existence.


If the approach we use to determine the existence of real objects is different than the approach you use to determine the existence of allah, then how do we know your approach even works?


Quote:
Another example is have them consider what might happen if a tornado came through a junkyard and tore through the old cars; would it leave behind a nice new Mercedes with the engine running and no parts left around? Naturally not.


This comparison fails.

No one is saying any complex system came into existence suddenly by joining useless separate pieces into a fully functioning ideal.


Quote:
Or ask someone to consider what it would be like if someone told us about a fast food restaurant operating itself without any people there? The food just cooks itself, files from the kitchen to the table and then when we are done, the dishes jump back the kitchen to wash themselves. This is too crazy for anyone to even think about.


Well, because that would break established laws of physics.


Quote:
After reflecting on all of the above, how could we look to the universe above us through a telescope or observe the cells in a microscope and then think all of this came about as a result of a "big bang" or some "accident"?



Through deterministic forces (such as gravity), we can see simple things become complex things.


Do we need to posit a divine hand to explain the complexity of a snowflake? Does God craft each snowflake himself or do naturalistic forces do this automatically?
Rehmat
 
  0  
Reply Fri 16 Apr, 2010 06:08 pm
@Fatal Freedoms,
No need to prove it. Such knowledge is not meant for the morally corrupt Zionists and Atheists.
abd alrahem
 
  1  
Reply Sat 17 Apr, 2010 09:03 am
@Fatal Freedoms,
Fatal_Freedoms;71268 wrote:
This is a common misconception.


Just as their are those who believe in God and do bad things and yet are not worried about them. There are those who don't believe in god and yet do good things.

Whether someone is or isn't afraid of the consequences is irrelevant to whether they believe in god or not. It just isn't a factor. Some people are just naturally skeptical and some people are just naturally faithful.




I'm sure you've made up your mind just as much as they have made up theirs.



If the approach we use to determine the existence of real objects is different than the approach you use to determine the existence of allah, then how do we know your approach even works?




This comparison fails.

No one is saying any complex system came into existence suddenly by joining useless separate pieces into a fully functioning ideal.




Well, because that would break established laws of physics.





Through deterministic forces (such as gravity), we can see simple things become complex things.


Do we need to posit a divine hand to explain the complexity of a snowflake? Does God craft each snowflake himself or do naturalistic forces do this automatically?


for example,
did the computer in your home from chancing??


when you believe that the clock ,car and computer -for example-need the maker ,you will believe that rocks, snow, hydrogen atoms are made by Allah/God,and there is another question....Can you made a hydrogen atoms???
if you can not made an atom....the chancing????no ....what about the world??
hydrogen atoms is also complex .....very complex
look for example: all scientists can not make a live cell...do you know that ....how this cell , atom or any thing in the world make them selves????
it is impossible!!!!

your speech is imposible.

look again...
the human body is made up of for substances:hydrogen,oxygen,carbon and nitrogen ...if you mix this substances with each other and stay wait ...is it possible this substances make the human body by chancing ???
the answer no but ,yes with maker ,this maker is Allah/God.

think!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Allah/God made you in your mother's uterus ,when you see the light ...Allah make a lode in your mother's breast ...this lode give you a cold milk in summer and a warm milk in winter ..Are all these things is by chancing ????....No and thousand(No)

on the other hand:
the world is made up of -many basic substances- go to a laboratory and mix these substances together and do not forget the gravity....and wait your chancing .....Is this chancing able to create a small world to you ??NO

hear to this.
do you hear that a car move you from city to city without any driver or so far control ?????it is impossible.so,who drive all operation in the world.
any thing in the world .....need the creator,this maker is Allah/God,and the world do not exist without God.
Fatal Freedoms
 
  1  
Reply Sat 17 Apr, 2010 01:12 pm
@abd alrahem,
abd alrahem;71271 wrote:
for example,
did the computer in your home from chancing??


when you believe that the clock ,car and computer -for example-need the maker ,you will believe that rocks, snow, hydrogen atoms are made by Allah/God,and there is another question
Quote:


Why must it follow that if a man-made objects requires a designer, that natural objects require one as well?


Quote:
....Can you made a hydrogen atoms???
if you can not made an atom....the chancing????no ....what about the world??


No, I cannot make a hydrogen atom...

but gravity, elctro-static, chemical synthetic and other forces can make a hydrogen atom. In that sense you could say they are the creators, but nothing like the creator you are talking about.

Gravity does not plan, it does not think it just pulls things together unthinkingly and it will do this without fail. Gravity is a creator of worlds but it doesn't make much sense to worship gravity.




Quote:
hydrogen atoms is also complex .....very complex
look for example: all scientists can not make a live cell...do you know that ....how this cell , atom or any thing in the world make them selves????
it is impossible!!!!


No but living cells can form on their own given the right conditions.


Follow the Link:

Life As We Know It Nearly Created in Lab | LiveScience



I know you will not accept this or any other evidence I will give you, but you should at least look at it.


God may have even been the one who set these forces in motion, I don't know, but to say he magically "poofed" these things into existence or that he "designed" them is untenable.

Quote:
your speech is imposible.

look again...
the human body is made up of for substances:hydrogen,oxygen,carbon and nitrogen ...if you mix this substances with each other and stay wait ...is it possible this substances make the human body by chancing ???
the answer no but ,yes with maker ,this maker is Allah/God.

think!!!!!!!!!!!!!


The human body is made up of a lot more than 4 things, the human body is made up of a lot of elements and from those elements it's made up of a lot of different compounds.

You can't just throw all the ingredients together and hope something will happen, this is where your analogy fails. You wouldn't make a house by throwing some boards and nails in a pile would you? There is a specific process that things need to go through. First you need a foundation, then you need a frame, then you need walls and doors etc...

How things come together is just as important as what things come together.

For atoms these processes are usual chemical and happen all the time with or without a guiding force.




Quote:
Allah/God made you in your mother's uterus ,when you see the light ...Allah make a lode in your mother's breast ...this lode give you a cold milk in summer and a warm milk in winter ..Are all these things is by chancing ????....No and thousand(No)


No, the female lactation hormone when triggered is what makes the milk in a mother's breasts. The same way all other mammals lactate. This is through millions of years of evolution.

Why is it do you think that reptiles do not produce milk?




Quote:
on the other hand:
the world is made up of -many basic substances- go to a laboratory and mix these substances together and do not forget the gravity....and wait your chancing .....Is this chancing able to create a small world to you ??NO


Like I said above, you cannot make just my throwing all the ingredients together and hoping something will happen. There is a specific process things need to go through.



Quote:
hear to this.
do you hear that a car move you from city to city without any driver or so far control ?????it is impossible.so,who drive all operation in the world.
any thing in the world .....need the creator,this maker is Allah/God,and the world do not exist without God.


To say that somethings require an intelligent operator, therefore all things require an operator is a fundamentally flawed argument.
abd alrahem
 
  1  
Reply Mon 19 Apr, 2010 01:06 pm
@Fatal Freedoms,
Fatal_Freedoms;71272 wrote:


Why must it follow that if a man-made objects requires a designer, that natural objects require one as well?


you must believe in the creator because of this base,the world need creator to existing.

Fatal_Freedoms;71272 wrote:



No, I cannot make a hydrogen atom...

but gravity, elctro-static, chemical synthetic and other forces can make a hydrogen atom. In that sense you could say they are the creators, but nothing like the creator you are talking about.

Gravity does not plan, it does not think it just pulls things together unthinkingly and it will do this without fail. Gravity is a creator of worlds but it doesn't make much sense to worship gravity.




you are human , have mind ,and unable to create an atom,this prove the believing in Allah God.
about gravity.....go to the laboratory and uses gravity to mix the elements and wait .....i believe this operation is lost without creator.
and above of all these,you do not talk about the beginning of the substances,who create these substances to existing???

imagine that you have plastic pieces ,one letter is written on each pieces,if you throw a million of these pieces will not produce a big book with order by it self.







Fatal_Freedoms;71272 wrote:




You can't just throw all the ingredients together and hope something will happen, this is where your analogy fails. You wouldn't make a house by throwing some boards and nails in a pile would you? There is a specific process that things need to go through. First you need a foundation, then you need a frame, then you need walls and doors etc...


All operation on boards and nails (for example) prove that the chancing is unable to create the house and as result is unable to create the world.
and above of all these you forget the life!!!!!....the difference between the dead creaturs and the live creaturs,i mean :the issue of how make the subsatnce get a live,for example,dead insect in your home,do the chancing able to make her get a live for second ones??No.
the issue is more complex.


Fatal_Freedoms;71272 wrote:

For atoms these processes are usual chemical and happen all the time with or without a guiding force.



this is a big antimony with mind.


Fatal_Freedoms;71272 wrote:

No, the female lactation hormone when triggered is what makes the milk in a mother's breasts. The same way all other mammals lactate. This is through millions of years of evolution.

Why is it do you think that reptiles do not produce milk?






Like I said above, you cannot make just my throwing all the ingredients together and hoping something will happen. There is a specific process things need to go through.





To say that somethings require an intelligent operator, therefore all things require an operator is a fundamentally flawed argument.



the aphorism of Allah is make the human produce the milk,and reptiles not.


and above of all these,Islam have guides that Allah God is exist,the guides the miracles in quran and in the prophet Mouhammad's saying,for example:


you must read this example exactly:
first example:
Scientific Miracles in the Prophetic Teachings for a Cure of Anger



Here are some medical recommendations, published in one of the most important medical websites, to cure or avoid anger.

Psychology Help Center
second example:

The Miraculous Saying of Allah's Messenger (mouhammad)(PBUH): The drop of semen after forty two nights

and the photos in:


http://www.rasoulallah.net/subject_en.asp?lang=ar&parent_id=712&sub_id=8531


In what follows we shall review in pictures the development that the embryo undergoes when it passes 42 days in the womb and how the noble Hadith conforms to the scientific facts.

The sceptics had objected time and time again to the hadith of Allah's Messenger (PBUH) saying: "If a drop of semen spent in the womb forty two nights, Allah (the Almighty) sends an angel to it who depicts it and creates its ears, eyes, skin, flesh and bones." (Narrated by Muslim). They said that this hadith does not conform to modern science nor to the phases of the fetus development.

Science is really developing and revealing new facts and if we examine the recent researches in embryology and study the phase that Allah's Messenger (PBUH) had mentioned, when the embryo is 42 days old, what do we find? Why did the Messenger specify such age, 42 days, and what does it mean as regards the development of the fetus in his mother's womb? In what follows we exhibit a number of photos along with their explanation to show you how the embryo develops especially during the fifth, sixth and seventh week. Later we will get back to discover the perfect matching between the Prophet's hadith and the sayings of the contemporary scientists.





Photo 1



These are the stages by which the embryo passes starting by being a drop of semen all the way up until the end of the sixth week (42 days). We notice that the fetus does not take its human form except when it has completed 42 nights in the womb, such fact was confirmed by Allah's Messenger (PBUH) in the noble hadith. Take a note here of the shape of the drop of semen which does not resemble man, then it changes to a clot of blood which does not inspire any human shape, then it changes to a lump of flesh which again does not resemble man and when it is 42 days old the human shape appears clearly and it goes on until the end of pregnancy. Subhan Allah (glorified be Allah).





Photo 2




A real photo of a fetus five weeks old, in which we find no features of a human being. Scientists say that most of the animals take this form at such age, thus the embryo did not yet take its human form and we can see no ears, eyes, skin or bones.





Photo 3




A real photo for a 47 days old embryo, we notice that it has taken the human form and it is obvious that the ears, eyes and skin were being formed. All such features started to form by the end of the sixth week and they became obvious completely by the seventh week. The heart of the embryo starts beating clearly the sixth week.

To listen to the embryo's heart beat, click here



Photo 4






A photo comparing between a 5 week old embryo and another which is 8 weeks. Notice how the features, volume and shape have changed and how the humane form of the fetus became clear. Scientists say that as of the end of the sixth week, which is when the embryo is 42 days old; it starts to differentiate between the different voices and reacts to them. Scientists confirm that the age 42 days and what follows is a definitive border between the stage where the fetus is un-characteristic and that stage where that fetus takes its human form. That's why we find it mentioned on one of the sites that takes interest in the development of the fetus saying: - quoted word for word-

" During the sixth week after fertilization the unborn child can respond to local tactile stimulation by reflex movements. At the end of the sixth week, the unborn child is clearly recognizable as a human being by gross morphological observation. "

During the sixth week after fertilization the embryo starts responding to the outer effects by means of the reflexive movements. By the end of the sixth week we can easily, through observation, mark the embryo in the form of a human being. On another website we read their statement:

"The brainwaves have been noted at 43 days. Dr. Stiff has noted that electroencephalographic waves have been obtained in forty-three to forty-five day old fetuses, and so conscious experience is possible after this date".

Meaning, that the encephalic waves start when the fetus is 43 days old. Dr. Stiff noticed that the waves emitted from the brain can be measured at the age from 43-45 days, and in the same way the voluntary expressions can be observed after that age.





Photo 5





A photo of a six weeks old embryo, such age at which the fetus takes its human form and its brain starts emitting waves that can be measured by means of special apparatus. This is an indication that the brain cells had started their activity and this might also mean that his spirit had entered the body, Allah (the Almighty) knows best. Observe how the eyes are beginning to formulate. Scientists assure that the eyes opening starts to formulate at the age of six weeks and this goes in perfect harmony with Allah's Messenger (PBUH) saying "he gives it its shape and creates its hearing and seeing."

The eyes appear clearly at the 42nd day according to Keith Moore, the famous embryologist, who says: "the eye is obvious, about day 42 after fertilization "(Moore, p99).

After that 42 days have been fully completed the eyes and ears start developing rapidly:

" The eyes are developing rapidly, the ears are developing rapidly, 7th week after conception (Rugh, p 52). Science for Unborn Human Life | Appendix 1 | 6th Week.

The ears and eyes develop rapidly during the seventh week (after the drop of semen had passed 42 days in the womb). This means that the fetus takes its human form by the end of the sixth week, such fact is stated accurately & clearly in the Prophetic hadith:" If a drop of semen remained in the womb for forty two nights Allah (the Almighty) sends an angel to it who depicts it and creates its ears, eyes, skin, flesh and bones."





Photo 6




Let us study these two photos: one of them is when the fetus is 41 days old and until this moment we can't distinguish its human form but after the 42nd day, which is the second photo, his human form is seen clearly. That's why in the left photo we observe the features of a human embryo with apparent ears and eyes and also the feet, hands and fingers, glorified be Allah (the Almighty). After witnessing a horrific number of abortions in the non Islamic countries, there are many campaigns against such abortions today. Scientists and researchers are embarking on a study to designate the age after which abortion is to be prohibited. They found out that the brain of fetus at the end of sixth and the beginning of the seventh week (meaning when the fetus is 42 days old), starts emitting waves which proves the start of life, so they suggest that the embryo cannot be killed after that age.

Here I recollect with you the instance in which some of our legists had made use of such hadith of our greatest Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) and deduced that it is impermissible to abort a child who is 42 nights old, Even though an abortion can be performed before this age if there was a medical necessity that calls for that.

This is such a wonderful prophetic hint that the spirit is instilled in the embryo at this specific age. At such age (42 days) waves released from the brain were measured and also heart beats were recorded, all of this suggests that there is a relation between the spirit and the operation of the brain and heart. Allah (the Almighty) knows best.





Photo 7





A fetus in real size of 42 days old of age which has started to take its human form, observe here how small it is, even though he is considered a fully developed human being as far as the shape is concerned. Thus some scientists say that abortion is impermissible of that fetus because it is considered a full human being.







Photo 8




A fetus training itself to suck its finger for the preparation of getting out to the world and starting to suck its mother's breast, so all praise is due to Allah who had taught this child that which it does not know, who said: " And Allah brought you out of your mothers' bellies not knowing anything, and He has made for you hearing and be holdings (i.e. eyesight) and heart-sights, (i.e., perception "s") that possibly you would thank (Him)."

The question is what does all that mean?

It means that there are radical changes that occur immediately after the fetus is 42 days old. On the 43rd day the brain starts emitting waves and the embryo begins reacting with its surrounding environment and starts feeling. It means that the spirit had started its activity in the body of the embryo. It also means that the greatest Prophet (PBUH) had preceded the western scientists in telling us about such a specific issue which no man could have ever predicted fourteen centuries ago. This means that no one can provide such data about this stage unless he is a specialized doctor who had all the necessary equipment. Was Allah's Messenger (PBUH) a doctor who had such devices? Here we have to stop again and ask those sceptics: how did the greatest Prophet (PBUH) know that exactly after 42 days the drop of semen will turn into a human being who has ears, eyes, skin and bones??!

third example:
The Prohibition of Carrion, Blood, the Flesh of Swine, and that which has been Acclaimed to Other than Allah:

forth example:
The Prophet would never Deceive himself!?



We created man from an extract of clay. Then We made him as a drop in a place of settlement, firmly fixed. Then We made the drop into an alaqah (leech, suspended thing, and blood clot), then We made the alaqah into a mudghah (chewed substance)... 1 (Quran, 23:12-14)

Literally, the Arabic word alaqah has three meanings: (1) leech, (2) suspended thing, and (3) blood clot.

In comparing a leech to an embryo in the alaqah stage, we find similarity between the two2 as we can see in figure 1. Also, the embryo at this stage obtains nourishment from the blood of the mother, similar to the leech, which feeds on the blood of others.3

Figure1 in this link:
A Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam, Muslims, and the QuranA Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam, Muslims, and the Quran
Figure 2: We can see in this diagram the suspension of an embryo during the alaqah stage in the womb (uterus) of the mother. (The Developing Human, Moore and Persaud, 5th ed., p. 66.) (Click on the image to enlarge it.)

Figure3 in this link:
A Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam, Muslims, and the QuranA Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam, Muslims, and the QuranA Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam, Muslims, and the Quran

Figure 5: Photograph of an embryo at the mudghah stage (28 days old). The embryo at this stage acquires the appearance of a chewed substance, because the somites at the back of the embryo somewhat resemble teeth marks in a chewed substance. The actual size of the embryo is 4 mm. (The Developing Human, Moore and Persaud, 5th ed., p. 82, from Professor Hideo Nishimura, Kyoto University, Kyoto, Japan.)


Figure 6 in this link:
A Brief Illustrated Guide To Understanding Islam, Muslims, and the Quransixth example:


the seven Earths
and there are a lot of miracles in Quran and the prophet's saying,
the bases of Islam is very strong and thank Allah God for that,
but,
where is your guides?where?
muslims is interesting in comfortable self and thank Allah God for that.
Fatal Freedoms
 
  1  
Reply Mon 19 Apr, 2010 04:31 pm
@abd alrahem,
abd alrahem;71287 wrote:
you must believe in the creator because of this base,the world need creator to existing.


No, I'm telling you that this is an unnecessary assumption that you have. I'm asking you to make rational sense of your assumption.



Quote:
you are human , have mind ,and unable to create an atom,this prove the believing in Allah God.


How does my inability to create an atom prove that god did it?



Quote:
about gravity.....go to the laboratory and uses gravity to mix the elements and wait .....i believe this operation is lost without creator.


Again you are still using the same failed analogy, we cannot throw things together and expect something to happen, you know nothing will happen and I know nothing will happen...yet you think this proves your beliefs. It does not.




Quote:

and above of all these,you do not talk about the beginning of the substances,who create these substances to existing???


I do not talk of that I do not know. I do not what the begging is, or how it began. If there even is a beginning to speak of.

Unlike you, I do not pretend to know. I can only show you what the evidence says.


I believe matter is timeless.



Quote:

imagine that you have plastic pieces ,one letter is written on each pieces,if you throw a million of these pieces will not produce a big book with order by it self.


Deterministic forces are not driven by chance. Is it chance that a river flows down hill? No. You assume all natural things happens according to chance. This simply isn't true.



Quote:
All operation on boards and nails (for example) prove that the chancing is unable to create the house and as result is unable to create the world.
and above of all these you forget the life!!!!!....



But if you break something down into individual steps and show that each can happen through some natural process, as scientists have done, this contradicts your claims.

Water evaporates by a natural process, water vapor collects as clouds by a natural process, and water condenses in these cloud and falls as rain through a natural process. Rain does not happen by chance, it is bound to happen from deterministic natural processes.

No rain maker is required.



Quote:
the difference between the dead creaturs and the live creaturs,i mean :the issue of how make the subsatnce get a live,for example,dead insect in your home,do the chancing able to make her get a live for second ones??No.
the issue is more complex.


What? I don't know what your saying.



Quote:

this is a big antimony with mind.


??



Quote:
the aphorism of Allah is make the human produce the milk,and reptiles not.


Why? Why do mammals produce milk and not reptiles?




Quote:
and above of all these,Islam have guides that Allah God is exist,the guides the miracles in quran and in the prophet Mouhammad's saying,for example:


The Quran is wrong.
abd alrahem
 
  1  
Reply Thu 22 Apr, 2010 08:37 am
@Fatal Freedoms,
Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:


How does my inability to create an atom prove that god did it?




this exactly prove that Allah is exist because:
you are unable to create ,chancing also are unable to create,and any force are unable to create the world ....go back to the laboratory example,and use any force you need .....without Allah the creator you won't take any thing.





Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:

Again you are still using the same failed analogy, we cannot throw things together and expect something to happen, you know nothing will happen and I know nothing will happen...yet you think this proves your beliefs. It does not.






this proves the failing of chaning to produce the universe,i think this admitting.



Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:

I do not talk of that I do not know. I do not what the begging is, or how it began. If there even is a beginning to speak of.

Unlike you, I do not pretend to know. I can only show you what the evidence says.


I believe matter is timeless.




hear,
can you prove your speech for one in your life???
did you notice that you talk and talk about force and .....WITHOUT ANY GUIDE.
islam prove his bases to you when i said to you about the miracles in quran and the prophet's saying,but you did not prove any thing you talk and suppose without guides,so go back and read the articles above about the miracles in islam,and these miracles prove that the islam bases are honest.




Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:

Deterministic forces are not driven by chance. Is it chance that a river flows down hill? No. You assume all natural things happens according to chance. This simply isn't true.



But if you break something down into individual steps and show that each can happen through some natural process, as scientists have done, this contradicts your claims.

Water evaporates by a natural process, water vapor collects as clouds by a natural process, and water condenses in these cloud and falls as rain through a natural process. Rain does not happen by chance, it is bound to happen from deterministic natural processes.

No rain maker is required.





Allah is driving the forces in the universe because of the causality law,the causality law have many bases such as "we have a pen on the desk,this pen is static,the forces around pen move it to other place,but pen is unable to move it self without mover this move is the force around it ,and this force need driver"ok let go back to our talk the rain ,cloud and wind need mover.



Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:

What? I don't know what your saying.




i said if you have a dead insect,you are unable to make it a live one and the forces in the universe also unable because: Are these force produce a computer or a simple pen?..the answer no ,so how these forces can produce the human ,animals ,earth ,sun.
on the other hand,you did not answer me about my question:"who create the substances in the world???"









Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:

Why? Why do mammals produce milk and not reptiles?


the aphorism of Allah is make the human produce the milk,and reptiles not. and as i say "islam have the guides and miracles such the miracles above,but you have none"




Fatal_Freedoms;71291 wrote:



The Quran is wrong.

http://www.rasoulallah.net/
Islam Guide: A Brief Illustrated Guide to Understanding Islam, Muslims, & the Quran

Iman Way ... Call to Islam - Iman Way
Iman Way
????? ????? ??? ????????
what is islam ?
Huda TV
Banadir24.com - Quran
The Religion of Islam
maverick cv
 
  1  
Reply Fri 23 Apr, 2010 06:24 am
@Rehmat,
Rehmat;71269 wrote:
No need to prove it. Such knowledge is not meant for the morally corrupt Zionists and Atheists.


Yes right- Ask them to first prove that god is not there. If they do so there will be lots of examples to prove that HE exists.
0 Replies
 
maverick cv
 
  1  
Reply Fri 23 Apr, 2010 06:32 am
@Fatal Freedoms,
Why to just talk about making of things- the simple question to be asked is can u pump life into Dead. may be someday we can make earth or hydrogen but can we make life. We are not even able to replicate blood, forget the life.

Its harder fact to accept that there is god and even more harder to accept that He is not.

Go according to Physics theorems.

Assume that there is god,
work out the equations (day to day life),
and finally at the end of theorem get the answer.

The thing is that each of us has to solve it on his own, nor i can let u know the end result nor can u show me yours.

So go on and Assume, as assumptions solves most of the physics theorems and hope it solves this too.
0 Replies
 
nickos
 
  1  
Reply Sat 8 May, 2010 09:17 pm
@abd alrahem,
first of all, it's IMPOSSIBLE to prove beyond doubt that 'god' exists. first you have to realise that the word god means 'all angels'.gabriel was the messenger from 'god' at the time of jesus. it changes every century-with my own 'messiah complex' it was the late great patrick wheeler(uncle to the frontman of the band Ash(3 wise men)). you'll probably think me insane but wait just there!check my site first;S.A.K.I.:Sun and King Index - Home
i WAS anointed whether it be by a 'star of wonder',or Zeus' lightning bolt, or Thor's lightning bolt,or the 'shower of gold' which perseus 'was born under, in a cave'!
please do check my site and just try to put yourselves in my shoes! i was also 'portrayed as the king of heaven', which my site will give more detail on...
0 Replies
 
Fatal Freedoms
 
  1  
Reply Sun 9 May, 2010 09:37 pm
@abd alrahem,
abd alrahem;71335 wrote:
this exactly prove that Allah is exist because:
you are unable to create ,chancing also are unable to create,and any force are unable to create the world ....go back to the laboratory example,and use any force you need .....without Allah the creator you won't take any thing.


But natural forces are able to create the world 'as we know it'.

Every day stars explode. Everyday stars form. We know why this happens and we know how this happens. We can show the chemical processes that cause this. We can even make accurate predictions based on this knowledge.

You cannot forsaken the utility of science, without forsaking the wealth of knowledge that brought you modern society.


Quote:
this proves the failing of chaning to produce the universe,i think this admitting.


I am not talking about things coming together by chance, I am talking about things that are 'bound' to happen sooner or later.






Quote:
hear,
can you prove your speech for one in your life???
did you notice that you talk and talk about force and .....WITHOUT ANY GUIDE.
islam prove his bases to you when i said to you about the miracles in quran and the prophet's saying,but you did not prove any thing you talk and suppose without guides,so go back and read the articles above about the miracles in islam,and these miracles prove that the islam bases are honest.


And yet i hear from christians all of the time telling me how the miracles of the bible prove it's authenticity, I have even heard from hindus who claims the divine knowledge of the Vedas. Why should I believe you over them?

All of them are man-made religions. Created from superstition and myth.


Quote:
Allah is driving the forces in the universe because of the causality law,the causality law have many bases such as "we have a pen on the desk,this pen is static,the forces around pen move it to other place,but pen is unable to move it self without mover this move is the force around it ,and this force need driver"ok let go back to our talk the rain ,cloud and wind need mover.


The wind is moved by changing air-temperature and clouds are moved by the wind. There is no reason to posit that an invisible deity does this.




Quote:
i said if you have a dead insect,you are unable to make it a live one and the forces in the universe also unable because:


okay so if any animal or insect magically springs back to life days after it's death, then i suppose that would be a good argument for a God. But until that happens you have no argument here.

Quote:

Are these force produce a computer or a simple pen?..the answer no ,so how these forces can produce the human ,animals ,earth ,sun.


Because humans and animals are organic.


Quote:
on the other hand,you did not answer me about my question:"who create the substances in the world???"


Yes I did, I said "I don't know, I believe that matter/energy is timeless (it was not created, it always existed).

Quote:

the aphorism of Allah is make the human produce the milk,and reptiles not.


And why is that?


Quote:
and as i say "islam have the guides and miracles such the miracles above,but you have none"


I don't need miracles. I have the power, of reason, logic, science, and evidence.
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

 
  1. Forums
  2. » how can we prove there is a God
Copyright © 2024 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.07 seconds on 04/16/2024 at 08:05:02