Who should be able to get press credentials?

Reply Sun 29 Nov, 2009 05:57 pm
Should bloggers be able to get press credentials?
What kind of restrictions should be overcome to get a press credential? Who should be barred if any from being able to get a press credential?

Publisher Reports: (Some) Bloggers (May) Get Press Passes
Long-time readers of Gothamist may remember that we've applied for NYPD press passes a couple of times, and have gotten denied. The explanation we were given was that the NYPD only credentials traditional media" radio, print, and television" and that online reportage simply did not qualify. So it was with great interest that we attended today's public discussion of "Rules for City Issued Press Credentials" at New York Law School.

As part of a proposed settlement of a lawsuit brought by Norman Siegel on behalf of three online-journalists that had their applications for press passes denied, the city has agreed to consider revising the press pass rules. As part of that process, Gabriel Taussig of the New York City Law Department and Siegel outlined the proposed new rules for the three dozen journalists, bloggers, and other concerned citizens who showed up, and solicited some feedback. Here is an overview:

Restrictions limiting press passes to certain mediums will be removed" in the future, online, offline, on-air, etc. will all be treated equally.
To qualify for a press pass, the journalist or journalism organization will need to provide six clips from the last 24 months showing news-gathering activity that would require a press card" that would include live reportage from police and fire scenes, public assemblies, government press conferences, or similar events.
The new system will consist entirely of working press cards, reserve cards (issued to freelancers by a news organization), and single-event cards. The other press cards that were issued as a courtesy (but didn't allow the reporter to cross police or fire lines) will be eliminated.
If an applicant for a press card is denied, there is a formal process to appeal, in which the city has a set period of time (90 days) to respond to the appeal. Previously, the city had no time limit for response, and applications often fell into a black hole of city bureaucracy.
After their presentation, people in the audience were allowed to ask questions. One of the main criticisms brought up is that it's difficult for a freelancer to assemble six clips without a press card, and without those clips the freelancer can't get a press card, creating a chicken-and-egg situation. Some of the mainstream organizations also wondered whether their managing editors would be allowed to get cards, given that they only report from scenes infrequently, but still need the cards for big emergencies like 9-11 or the Transit Strike. Other reporters were concerned the NYPD doesn't train its officers to respect press passes, and that the reserve press cards (which have no picture) are often impossible to use. And finally, some of the bloggers in the audience worried that the NYPD might reject our clips because they didn't have enough "on-the-scene" reportage, and the definition of that is vague. Does one fact reported from the scene count, or do you have to include an interview with a witness? What about a picture?

While most agreed that revising the rules was a good idea, some of the mainstream reporters worried that hordes of bloggers might block their access to important events. Siegel said that he did not expect it be an issue (he pointed out that even Mayor Bloomberg's press conferences are rarely oversubscribed) but if it did become a problem, the various parties would gather again to determine a solution.

Under the new rules, it seems like Gothamist would qualify for the new credentials. Once the new rules go into effect (a process that will take many months), we'll have each of our full time writers and editors apply, and we'll also ask for a couple of reserve cards for our interns and freelancers. We'll report back once we're approved or denied. It is our hope that with the new rules, the playing field for bloggers and professional journalists will become a little more level, and we'll have access to the same sources and scenes that current mainstream journalists take for granted. Hopefully, as a result, the quality of our reportage will improve, and we'll be able to pick up some of the burden being shed by the dying mainstream media organizations.

  • Topic Stats
  • Top Replies
  • Link to this Topic
Type: Discussion • Score: 2 • Views: 2,798 • Replies: 4
No top replies

Reply Sun 27 Dec, 2009 07:25 am
do u know when this will go into effect?


[email protected]

Reply Sun 27 Dec, 2009 07:32 am
i should be able to get a press pass, i think i'd look pretty cool in this

Reply Sun 27 Dec, 2009 10:06 am
I like! What other colors does it come in? Hmm?
0 Replies
Reply Sun 27 Dec, 2009 08:17 pm
photosbyhe: Welcome to a2k. The NYPD site is pretty vague on the details but if you have the fee to burn I'd try it if I were you. Then dispute it if they have the audacity to turn down your request.

Press Relations | Credentials
Press Credentials

Please read the instructions before you complete the on-line press credential request form. After you have read and complied with the instructions below, you can print the form and complete it.

Download: Press Credentials Application

NOTE: Upon completion of the application, applicants should call the Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Public Information between the hours of 9 AM and 5 PM Monday through Friday to schedule an appointment. No applications can be accepted by mail.

Press Credential On-line Application Instructions

This application is to be completed by each applicant (printed or typed) and certified by your Editor/News Director only. Department Supervisors are not authorized to certify applications.

Working Press Cards are for those individuals who are full-time, news staff employees, whose routine duties require them to cross police and fire lines and are regularly involved in spot emergency news coverage, i.e.; shootings, fires, homicides, etc.

Press Identification Cards are issued to full-time members of the press who do not hold the Working Press Cards but do have a need for an official Police Department identification card in order to fulfill their various assignments of crossing police lines at the scene of a "non-emergency" news event such as a parade, theatre premiere, etc.. Press Identification cards will not be granted to individuals who are employed in the business, advertising or circulation departments.

Press Vehicle Cards will only be issued to staff who also apply and qualify for the Working Press Card. In order to receive this card a current copy of the applicant's motor vehicle registration and a cover letter from applicants News Director/Editor requesting permit must be included with their application.

First time and renewal applicants must include the following items with their application, should any items be omitted the application will be returned.
A cover letter from the applicant’s News Director/Editor requesting credentials for the individual. (If numerous applications are being filed one letter with all the applicants names will suffice.)
Three (3) tear sheets attributed to the applicant for print media.*
Radio and television applicants must submit a VHS tape or audio tape of their work. (This tape will be returned)*
Organizations applying for the first time should contact D.C.P.I. for assistance.
Independently employed applicants must submit a reference letter from at least TWO agencies that have recently hired them on a freelance basis and the Company Name box on the application should be filled in with self employed.
* All documented work must be within the previous six months and must demonstrate a need for credentials.

Working Press Reserve Cards, Press Vehicle Cards and Reserve Press Vehicle Cards are applied for by the agency News Director/Editor on company letterhead indicating the amount needed. These cards are issued in a limited capacity and should be given out on a controlled basis by the News Director/Editor.

0 Replies

Related Topics

So I just joined Facebook.... - Discussion by DrewDad
YouTube Is Doomed - Discussion by Shapeless
Internet disinformation overload - Discussion by rosborne979
Participatory Democracy Online - Discussion by wandeljw
OpenDNS and net neutrality - Question by Butrflynet
Internet Explorer 8? - Question by Pitter
  1. Forums
  2. » Who should be able to get press credentials?
Copyright © 2023 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.04 seconds on 02/05/2023 at 08:04:33