Re: The music is just another actor?
Thomas wrote:boomerang wrote:What movies can you think of where the music was a good actor?
The Third Man
The Graduate
Pulp Fiction
I've been thinking about this question. I don't think the music's been an actor in our choices - it's something else but I'm not sure what to call it. For example, the pool scene in the Graduate (Dustin underwater and S&G's Sound Of Silence).
I keep thinking of the different impact that scene would have if you replaced SOS with Nirvana's 'Smells like teen spirit' or Boston's 'More than a feeling' or Wagner's 'Ride of the Valkyrie' or Robert Fripp's 'Haaden Two' or 'I'm forever blowing bubbles'.
Music in film is an emotional signifier. It informs you of things that only a combination of backstory, acting talent and effectivescript writing could. I think it can be a psychic channel to a character's emotional state. But in the Jaws example it's something else. It subliminally magnifies the tension and dread already implicit in the onscreen action. I don't think an actor can do any of those things I've mentioned.
What's more music can be used as Spakfilla (sorry - don't know a non-Oz term for that) for cinema that doesn't stand up on it's own, making up for wooden acting, bad writing, poor direction and implausible story lines.
I'VE GOT IT!!!!! Music in film is salt in food.
It can bring out the flavour
It can override the flavour and make your mouth catsbum
It can be the only flavour in a tasteless dish, making it edible but unsatisfying.