ossobuco wrote:Hey, I lived in NYC when I was nine, and a fine time it was, to be nine, and there. Took me a long time to visit again, for varied reasons, but I still have a little Manhattan in my blood.
I couldn't begin to generalize about Manhattan seriously. Sure, there's a portion of the population that is on parade (see The Sartorialist, which relates at least somewhat to the fashion industry, but also photos street folk.) Which doesn't matter - that I can't generalize - as the city is in flux.
The verve of the place, to me, is the flux.
O.K., but without sounding racist, I know that New York City once had a quite different demographic. For example, one-third of New York City was either Irish or Irish-American (circa 1950). And, they lived in the five boroughs. A very different city.
They were, in my opinion, too upwardly mobile to stay. But, if you have ever watched the old black and white movies from the 1940's, you'll know what I mean. I believe there was more glamor, more verve then.
Today the Upper East Siders, Upper West Siders, those living around Columbia, often tend to look like Manhattan is their piece of Nirvana. I believe that's because they are mostly transplants, and don't remember a better city (as far as the "quality of life.")
Today's verve, in my opinion, is many young people shopping in SoHo, clubbing here and there, or tourists visiting Ground Zero, Wall Street, Times Square, Herald Square, museums, etc.
In my own worthless opinion, NYC is not, nor can ever be, what it once was. Also, the condo's/co-ops are now a fair percentage of wealthy foreigners. Are there any rentals that are not high priced, compared to the 1980's? (Seinfeld wouldn't be believable today with he and his friends affording a rental in the west 80's.) I won't mention "the projects," since that broaches a subject outside this thread. Signs in the subway can be in any number of languages.
I'll give one personal fact. My family arrived in Manhattan in 1882. My father was born there and died there. He had the best years of Manhattan. Do you wonder why I think "the city" has changed?