1
   

Arabs Shocked, Relieved at Baghdad's Fall

 
 
Reply Thu 10 Apr, 2003 09:43 am
Arabs Shocked, Relieved at Baghdad's Fall
Wed Apr 9, 3:54 PM ET
By DONNA ABU-NASR, Associated Press Writer

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia - The fall of Baghdad provoked shock and disbelief Wednesday among Arabs, who expressed hope that other oppressive regimes would crumble but also disappointment that Saddam Hussein (news - web sites) did not put up a better fight against America.

"Why did he fall that way? Why so fast?" said Yemeni homemaker Umm Ahmed, tears streaming down her face. "He's a coward. Now I feel sorry for his people."

Arabs clustered at TV sets in shop windows, coffee shops, kitchens and offices to watch the astounding pictures of U.S. troops overwhelming an Arab capital for the first time ever. Feeling betrayed and misled, some turned off their sets in disgust when jubilant crowds in Baghdad celebrated the arrival of U.S. troops.

"We discovered that all what the (Iraqi) information minister was saying was all lies," said Ali Hassan, a government employee in Cairo, Egypt. "Now no one believes Al-Jazeera anymore."

In a live report from Baghdad, correspondent Shaker Hamed of Abu Dhabi Television said:"We are all in shock. How did things come to such an end? How did U.S. tanks enter the center of the city? Where is the resistance? This collapse is puzzling. Was it the result of the collapse of communications between the commanders? Between the political leadership? How come Baghdad falls so easily."

Mohammed al-Shahhal, a 49-year-old teacher in Tripoli, Lebanon, said the scenes reminded him of the collapse of the Soviet Union. "Those who applauded the collapse of Lenin's statue for some Pepsi and hamburgers felt the hunger later on and regretted what they did," al-Shahhal said.

However, Tannous Basil, a 47-year-old cardiologist in Sidon, Lebanon, said Saddam's regime was a "dictatorship and had to go." "I don't like the idea of having the Americans here, but we asked for it," he said. "Why don't we see the Americans going to Finland, for example? They come here because our area is filled with dictatorships like Saddam's."

Tarek al-Absi, a Yemeni university professor, was hopeful Saddam's end presaged more democracy in the region. "This is a message for the Arab regimes, and could be the beginning of transformation in the Arab region," al-Absi said. "Without the honest help of the Western nations, the reforms will not take place in these countries."

The overwhelming emotions for many Arabs were disbelief or disillusionment after weeks of hearing Saddam's government pledge a "great victory" or fight to the death against "infidel invaders."

"We Arabs are clever only at talking," Haitham Baghdadi, 45, said bitterly in Damascus, Syria. "Where are the Iraqi weapons? Where are the Iraqi soldiers?"

Many resorted to conspiracy theories to explain the rapid collapse.
"There must have been treason," said Ahmed Salem Batmira, an Omani political analyst. "It seems there was some deal. Saddam has put himself ahead of his people," said Yemeni government employee Saad Salem el-Faqih, 50. Three men having tea and smoking in a coffee shop in Riyadh were unsettled as they watched the TV ?- even though they said they were against Saddam and felt sorry for the long-suffering Iraqis.

"I can't say that I'm happy about what's going on because these are non-Muslim forces that have gone in and I hope they will not stay," said Mohammed al-Sakkaf, a 58-year-old businessman.

Many said they were disturbed by images of U.S. troops lounging in Saddam's palaces or draping the U.S. flag around the head of a Saddam statue. "Liberation is nobler than that," said Walid Abdul-Rahman, one of the three Saudis. "They should not be so provocative."

In Jordan, hotel receptionist Wissam Fakhoury, 28, said he was disappointed in the Baghdad crowds. "I spit on them," he said. "Do those crowds who are saluting the Americans believe that the United States will let them live better?" Fakhoury said. Americans "will loot their oil and control their resources, leaving them nothing."

Bahraini physician Hassan Fakhro, 62, said he was saddened. "Whatever I'm seeing is very painful because although Saddam Hussein was a dictator, he represented some kind of Arab national resistance to the foreign invaders ?- the Americans and the British," Fakhro said.

After an anti-war march in Khartoum, Sudan, lawyer Ali Al-Sayed said U.S. troops should not misinterpret the relief as an invitation to stay. "Those people under oppression will not have any national feeling, so they will be happy to see someone removing a dictator and liberating them," al-Sayed said. "But the moment they feel free and liberated, they will not tolerate a foreign presence."

Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak (news - web sites), an uncomfortable U.S. ally in the war, said the quickest way to achieve stability now would be for U.S. troops to withdraw. "Iraqis must take control over of their country as fast as possible," Mubarak told Egypt's official news agency, MENA.

Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Saud, looking upset at a news conference, called for a quick end to Iraq 's "occupation." In a rare departure from diplomacy, Saud responded to a question about Arab anger toward the United States with: "I don't want to talk about anger if you don't mind today."
  • Topic Stats
  • Top Replies
  • Link to this Topic
Type: Discussion • Score: 1 • Views: 1,712 • Replies: 1
No top replies

 
BumbleBeeBoogie
 
  1  
Reply Sat 12 Apr, 2003 09:43 am
At a Tea Shop in Cairo, Disbelief at War Reports
At a Tea Shop in Cairo, Disbelief at War Reports
By SUSAN SACHS
CAIRO, April 12 ?- They just do not believe it.

Those Iraqis who stamped and spit on the fallen statue of Saddam Hussein? Those were Kurds maybe, but not Arabs, insisted the men of Nasr Street, sipping sweet tea on the sidewalk on a sunny afternoon.

"I'm sure the Iraqi people did not do that themselves," said Hamdi Mahmoud, an accountant relaxing in a chocolate-colored robe on his day off. "Millions loved Saddam."

American marines welcomed in central Baghdad? Another clever fabrication, his friends agreed. "The media must be hiding something," said Hanafi Abu Saleh, a television repairman. "If Iraqis are so happy, why are they still fighting?"

It was Friday afternoon in the Imbaba section of central Cairo, and the men were in their usual chairs at the Saafan tea shop.

The butcher sliced meat from a haunch of beef hanging in his doorway. Clothes flapped in the breeze on the balconies like multicolored flags. Cars honked as they passed donkeys pulling carts piled high with fragrant fresh garlic or watermelons.

Far away in Washington, President Bush was proclaiming the liberation of Iraq. Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld was telling Arabs that the televised images from Baghdad were proof that "America is a friend to the Arab people."

The men at the cafe were having none of it. The images they remembered from satellite television and Egyptian stations during the war left an entirely different impression.

"After the Egyptian people have seen this, all this killing of women and children, they think that Bush is a bloodsucker," said Mr. Mahmoud, a forceful speaker who was convinced that the United States would never be trusted in the region.

"Bush decided to launch this war because of weapons of mass destruction," he said. "Where are they? This war was launched to protect Israel. What about the Arab countries? Aren't we threatened by Israel's mass destruction weapons?"

A few tables away, two men concentrated on a chess game, using worn wooden pieces from a battered cardboard box. Slowly a crowd gathered to hear the conversation.

At the edge of the group stood a young man wearing a T-shirt that declared, "No attack on Iraq."

"He wanted to go and fight in Iraq," said Mr. Saleh, pointing at him. "Tell them."

But the younger man, seized with paralyzing shyness, just nodded.

"All the Egyptian people wanted to go," continued Mr. Saleh, a veteran of the Egyptian Army's war in Yemen in the early 1960's. "I would go, to defend the Arab nation and the Islamic religion."

The talk grew more heated. Why did Mr. Bush do this? they asked. Why did so many Iraqi children die? "Didn't you see the little girl in the hospital with all the blood?" asked Tarek Ali, a construction worker brandishing the tube of his water pipe.

Abruptly, another middle-aged man stalked off. "My blood pressure gets too high when I think of this war," he said as he left. "Anyway, the Americans brought Saddam Hussein to power, and now they are just hiding him to justify staying in Iraq as occupiers."

With his departure, the men turned to the mysteries of the fall of Baghdad, a subject they embraced with relish and humor. They wondered about the Iraqi information minister, who had so delighted them each night on television with his colorful invectives against the Americans.

They speculated on the whereabouts of Mr. Hussein. Maybe the Russians are hiding him, one man volunteered. No, said another, there was a deal with the Americans.

The men, all in their 50's and 60's, rejected the idea that the outcome in Iraq was a humiliation for all Arabs. They had lived through the 1967 war against Israel.

That was a bad time, said Saleh Soleiman, a shopkeeper. "But we had our victory in 1973," he added, referring to Egypt's early rout of the Israelis from the Sinai in the first stages of a war Israel eventually won. Those days are relived constantly here.

The men worried out loud about the looting in Iraq, about the deadening effects of the war on Egypt's important tourism industry, about the possibility of Iraq's spinning apart into warring factions.

Maybe, they suggested hopefully, Iraq might soon hire Egyptian laborers, as it used to do before the gulf war in 1991, when some six million Egyptians worked there.

At one point the talk turned to the United Nations, and Mr. Soleiman began an analysis of the speech in which Secretary of State Colin L. Powell told the General Assembly that Iraq was hiding banned weapons. "He looked bad, don't you think?" asked Mr. Soleiman, the only one in the group to speak in English. "Weak evidence. Not convincing."

Much of the rage and passion that the men of Imbaba had been feeling about the war over the past three weeks had clearly begun to dissipate. No one cast an eye on the television set in the gloom of the tea shop.

Mr. Ali shrugged off whether the Iraqis were better off without Mr. Hussein. "Don't ask us this question," he said. "The Iraqis have their own feelings. They are living there. And whether they would overthrow him or not, it's too late to discuss it. I'm just sad to see the Iraqis suffering now."

The crowd of onlookers was thinning out. Men returned to their tea and quiet chats.

"America is a big empire, but it's thinking in terms of the imperialism of centuries ago," Mr. Soleiman said. "O.K. now, with this globalization we have economic occupation. But America has returned to the idea of military occupation."

He leaned back. "God makes us to enjoy life, not to kill people. In Egypt we have 7,000 years of civilization. Another country with just 200 years of civilization will not stand for a long time against the whole world."
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

 
  1. Forums
  2. » Arabs Shocked, Relieved at Baghdad's Fall
Copyright © 2026 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.03 seconds on 03/07/2026 at 01:07:03