@Jep32,
I have a couple questions here.
1) What would your relative do without Obama care?
2) Such a high deductible plan with a $1000/month subsidy seems untenable. What other options did she have?
3) How typical is this one example?
I think you are claiming that no one benefits from Obama care. I also think that it is pretty easy to show that this isn't true.
There are many people who do get decent insurance from Obamacare that they wouldn't have had otherwise. It is pretty easy to show that the number of uninsured Americans has gone down after Obamacare.
I personally believe that we should go to
single payer healthcare. This would be better than Obamacare by far in my opinion. I am not sure if we have the political will to get there (at least not yet).