Reply
Mon 24 Feb, 2003 09:47 am
Sharon moves Israel in opposite direction of peace - Fanatics on both sides make peace negotiation impossible, the goals of both extreme Arab and Jew religious parties.
------------------------------------------------
Sharon Forms Right-Leaning Coalition That May Make It Hard to
Relaunch Peace Talks
By Mark Lavie Associated Press Writer
Published: Feb 24, 2003
JERUSALEM (AP) - Prime Minister Ariel Sharon on Monday signed up the
secularist Shinui party, forming a right-leaning coalition that will likely make it difficult to move toward the establishment of a Palestinian state and could redefine the role of religion in the state.
The deal with Shinui gives Sharon control over 61 of the 120 seats in parliament, the minimum he needs to run the government. On Sunday, the pro-settlement National Religious Party, which opposes the
establishment of a Palestinian state, joined a Sharon government. The alliance of Sharon's hawkish Likud, the NRP and Shinui marks the first time ultra-Orthodox parties are not part of a Likud government.
The coalition agreement is vague on how to solve the conflict with the Palestinians. Coalition negotiators said it is based on a December speech in which Sharon called for the eventual establishment of a Palestinian state, but did not explicitly say he would dismantle Jewish settlements in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
The NRP leader, Effie Eitam, said the still-unpublished coalition guidelines "include absolutely no reference to removing or freezing settlements." Instead, he said, "they speak about enlarging settlements according to natural growth." Eitam, an ex-general, recently suggested the Palestinians set up their state in the Egyptian Sinai Desert.
Shinui is more moderate than the Likud or the NRP and supports the eventual creation of a Palestinian state. However, Shinui leader Yosef Lapid has said there is no point in resuming peace talks as long as Yasser Arafat is the Palestinian leader and attacks on Israelis continue. Shinui believes reaching a peace agreement is secondary to what it considers Israel's most pressing problem - perceived religious coercion and the disproportionate influence of ultra-Orthodox parties because of their longtime role as kingmakers in Israeli politics. The party nearly tripled its representation, from six to 15 parliament seats, in January's election.
The agreement allowed Sharon to avoid committing to specific steps toward resuming peace talks. Sharon's talks with the leader of the moderate Labor party, Amram Mitzna, broke down over his refusal to put in writing some of the painful concessions he claims he is prepared to make.
"He (Sharon) keeps saying he is ready for painful concessions in the future, but no one knows if he is bluffing," said political analyst Hanan Crystal. "He chose a government where he is in the middle. There are people right of him, and there are people left of him, and he remains the King of Israel."
Israeli media reported that Sharon was also close to agreement with the National Union, an ultranationalist bloc that includes members who favor expelling Palestinians from Israeli-ruled areas. Sharon's new coalition could put him on a collision course with the so-called Quartet of Mideast mediators - the United States, the European Union, the United Nations and Russia. The Quartet has formulated a three-stage "road map" to Palestinian statehood by 2005 that would include, among other things, a freeze of Jewish settlement construction.
Palestinian Cabinet Minister Saeb Erekat condemned Sharon for including NRP in his government, saying the "road map" would meet the same fate as other failed peace efforts.
"They have sent the road map into the archives along with the Mitchell and Tenet understandings," Erekat said, referring to other international deals meant to end more than two years of Israeli-Palestinian fighting and bring about a renewal of peace talks.
The new government could redefine the relationship between the secular majority and ultra-Orthodox minority. Shinui wants to revoke legislation that enables many Jewish seminary students to continue avoiding the draft, and has been promised the law would be replaced within a year. In the coalition agreement, Shinui was promised control of two key portfolios dealing with the role of religion in the state - justice and interior.
Among other things, the Interior Ministry determines who is classified as a Jew in the population registry. The ultra-Orthodox Shas party, which ran the ministry for many years, adopted strict criteria and repeatedly denied citizenship to new immigrants with non-Jewish family members.
I want to remind just one fact: in 1978 Mr. Sharon was a Defense Secretary of the government of Menachem Begin. And this government dismantled all the settlements[/i][/color] in the Sinai Peninsula in exchange for peace with Egypt.
The only things Palestinians must do to achieve progress in settlememts' problem is to prove that they mean peace. This implies immediate and unconditional ceasing of armed struggle and terror attacks. Then it will be possible to come to agreement that will lead to establishment of the Palestinian State. By side of Israel, and not instead of it[/i][/color].
BTW, Shas is going to lose its grip on the Interior Office. As far as I know, it is not supposed to be a part of the governing coalition.
Something more about Mr. Sharon and Israeli-Palestinian conflict:
The Other War
re. Shas, from the Jerusalem Post:
Code:The party's spiritual leader, Rabbi Ovadia Yosef,
called Sharon, "the king of garbage cans," and
compared Shinui to garbage and refuse. On the verge of tears, Yosef said that the National Religious Party behaved worse than anti-Semites by bringing a secularist party like Shinui into the government.
Thanks, Mr. Hinteler. The Shas leaders have very strange ideas of the civilized ways to express their disappointment...
Mr. Sharon really wants to establish the moderate and secular government. And if he fails, and establishes a narrow right-wing coalition, we can blame only the Leading Dove Mitzna that refused to cooperate...
Steissd: "In 1978 Mr. Sharon was a Defense Secretary of the government of Menachem Begin. And this government dismantled all the settlements in the Sinai Peninsula in exchange for peace with Egypt."
Steissd, I don't understand your statement re the Israel and Egypt peace agreement and how it applies to Israel and the Palestinians. Israel removed the Sinai settlements and peace with Egypt was achieved (though it cost Sadat his life and probably also Rabin's). The settlements disputed by the Palestinians have not been removed, in fact, they have expanded; hence no peace.
The settlements were not removed and they will not until the Palestinians prove that they mean peace, and not the multi-stage plan of dismantling of Israel. The intelligence services warned government in the very middle of the Oslo process, in tenure of Rabin about Palestinian plans to start the "exhaustion war" they really started in 2001 using Mr. Sharon's visit to the Temple Mount as an excuse. Their plan implies pushing more than one million of Arabs into Israel (in borders of 1967) and gradually becoming an ethnic majority there.