@Able2know1536,
It's weird that she calls the second guy dad but not so weird that she calls you by your first name. You are, after all, regardless of how much you love her, not her biological mother, who is still in the picture, who is with her more, and presumably is competent, loving, etc.
As for not embracing you immediately, it might just take her a while to get back in the swing of things with you. Keep in mind that she knows her father and her mother and her mother's boyfriend a lot better than she knows you.
I wouldn't look at it as a deliberate slight to get upset over (note: I am not a parent). A child in this situation is pulled in a million different directions and a four year old should not be expected to be sensitive to your feelings or responsible for managing them.
You are responsible for your own feelings and reactions, in this and in everything else in life. You are the one who is going to have to be more understanding in this dynamic.