@Helpmenow123,
Lela,
I am probably the only one here that will say do it. But let me explain my reasoning.
First of all the exact reason why I am not a fan of monogamy and or having just one romantic relationship is due to what you have already explain.
I think only having sexual experience with one person can cause problems long term. People are so different.
In a managomy-centric society most won't understand how you can love someone and care about them but still want to have another sexual experience with someone else. I say this is the ignored aspect of humanity that gets shunned a way for no good reason.
I think you are justified. But it could create a problem. Just keep this in mind. You could lose what you have over it. Is it worth that risk?