Reply
Tue 1 Dec, 2015 07:38 pm
A. Nobody defeats Dumbledore.
Defeat(x,y) = x defeats y. d = Dumbledore
B. Nobody who loves Dumbledore defeats him.
C. Somebody defeats Dumbledore -- but there is also someone who defeats them as well.
(Note that we are not saying that it is necessarily somebody else, who defeats the Dumbledore-defeater. Your translation should leave open the possibility that the Dumbledore-defeater is also someone who defeats themselves.)
D. If anybody can defeat Voldemort, then they must be Dumbledore.
v = Voldemort