@mariawolley,
Quote:I just want another professional opinion that will help me make up my mind
There isn't anyone here that gives professional medical opinions. Best thing to do is get a second opinion from an orthopedist who specializes in the feet and ankles.
If it were my ankle, I'd definitely want at least a second opinion regarding surgery.
I had a bad fall last December and fractured three vertebrae and dislocated my pelvis. What was thought to be a sprained ankle that swelled up but didn't give me much pain, has turned out to be two minor fractures in two spots of my foot and not the ankle. It hurts a great deal now when I walk a prolonged distance on it. It has already healed up, improperly because it was not reset and immobilized when it was fresh. The only thing they can do now is give me cortisone injections in those locations.
I wish i had gotten a second opinion, but at the time I was in agony and the foot pain seemed minor.
Get your medical advice in a doctor's office, not on the internet.