I dunno I'd say one was better, per se ... just that there are distinct and noticeable sonic differences. The current crop of CDs is far superior to those of the 80's and even early 90s, I think. My "Love of Vinyl" owes a lot to my enjoyment of lots of stuff that is not, and likely never will be, available on CD. Heck, some of my favorite recordings are Reel-to-Reel, half-track stereo recorded at 15 IPS right off the mixing board at bars and other tiny venues. And I KNOW those will never be commercially available. Got some great groups, too ... some known, some unknown. I like The Music much more than The Gear. All in all, Live is best, but I've never been able to get REO Speedwagon or Less McCann to show up at my house for a jam, so I listen to recordings