I think you are putting out the unattainable vibe. You are trying so hard to play hard to get that he thinks you would never pay attention to him. Trust me, only the most confident guys will try when they think they haven't got a chance.
Bella is right - talk to him. Ask him questions about himself. There are very few men who can resist a confident, classy woman who is interested in them!

But before you put all your hopes in him, make sure you realize that he may not be all he seems either. Use the time you talk to him to find out if you are really interested in him. Once you realize what lies behind his good looks and what makes him tick - you will know whether you want to go forward.
Anytime I used all my arsenal to reel them in before I knew who they were - I was sorry. Then I had to repel - and that just sucks. So - go forward with the "testing" phase - just to see - then proceed from there. Good luck!