OmSigDAVID wrote:I guess that raises the question of whether the citizens of the "strong nation" shoud be ROBBED
by their own governmentto give cash or other property to aliens;
a question of whether the government of that "strong nation"
was ever AUTHORIZED to do that, ...
Quote:From MY point of view
that's a short sighted and mean question.
If u r accosted by a French criminal
and
u defeat his attempts to
ROB u
maybe he will accuse u of being
short sighted n MEAN,
if u retain your property. U think ?
Francis wrote:
Quote:Nothing, in the constitutions of strong nations,
prevents governments to do so, let alone the benefits of said policy in the long run...
1 ) Really ?
I had in mind the 10th Amendment,
which provides that government has no power
other than what has been GRANTED to it.
Nowhere in the Constitution was power granted
to government to steal cash nor other property
from American citizens and give it to aliens.
If that had been in there
when it was submitted for Ratification,
it woud have been rejected out-of-hand.
2 ) When the nation began in 1789,
it was not "a strong nation".
Its Constitution was never amended to allow government
to rob its citizens to begift aliens.
Quote:A helping hand can be more than cash or property
Like
WHAT ?
Labor ?
That 's OK, if it is given freely,
if it is
NOT from a government funded group,
like the "Peace Corps" because the citizens who produced
that property
have a right TO KEEP IT.
David
